Posted by
Husker Jeff on Wednesday, November 15, 2006 2:17:54 PM
One of the Town Hall columnists and responses got me thinking today about race and racism. Does it exist? What are the impacts? What is the truth?
One of the first truths that I have come to is that racism is a real issue but that it is not based in any way upon race. Huh? To explain this, we have to discuss what is meant by race. In today's world, race is an issue of self identification and not one of genetics. I can as accurately say my race is "Republican Conservative" or "Catholic" as white, black, hispanic, or asian. I mean consider Tiger Woods. He is black right? Well, he says he is asian. So, lets look at his ancestors. Earl Wood's grandparents were two blacks, one ethnic chinese, and one amerind. Kultida Wood's grandparents were one ethnic chinese, one white, and two thai. So, Tiger is 1/4 african, 1/4 chinese, 1/4 thai, 1/8 white, and 1/8 amerind. BUT HE IS BLACK! Actually, no. He is more accurate when he says he is asian. After all he is 1/2 asian but only 1/4 black. But he looks black. And there we come to the crux. He has a skin hue that is a few shades darker than George Hamilton and a slightly wider nose. Even though his hair is more asian, that color makes him black.
Well, what do we do about a friend of mine. Her parents and her siblings all are varying shades from cafe au lait to semisweet chocolate, but she easily "passes for white" whenever she wants. Is she black? Her family says so and she says so, but if skin color is the determinate, nope, she is not.
How about hispanic? What is that? According to the best I can determine, a hispanic is anyone who speaks spanish as their original tongue, anyone who has a spanish, mexican, or latin american name, and anyone who comes from a latin american or south american country. Race?
Ah, but asian, there is a race. It encompasses mongolian, chinese, japanese, thai, burmese, korean, and even indian. Each of those would tell you that they are independent races with the indians being (in many cases) colored to semisweet chocolate darkness.
Well, everyone knows white folk. Germanics, italians, greeks, jews, eastern europeans, tartars.... Yup. That is one race... NOT. Well then jews. That one is easy. Sure. They are an arabic stock mainly and look almost identical to their muslim neighbors. Except for the northern african ones who are black colored. And their northern european ones who have inbred with the russians and tartars. Hmmm.
Enough of this. I think we can see that race is a blind and a dodge. In this world today, a person who is actually of a specific race (rather than of a specific appearance) is a rare thing. So, what we are talking about is appearance.
Is there bigotry based on appearance. ABSOLUTELY. Try to get a job in the executive suite of a major company looking like Danny DeVito. Short and fat. No matter how smart he is, unless he makes his own company, he is unlikely to be promoted. How about bigotry based on culture. Yes. Go to New York with a Georgia accent and see how you are treated. Go to Texas with a Boston accent and ask the same thing. This is not to say there is not and has not been a history of racism between the dominant culture and "people of color", but it is intended to show that if we eliminate the institutional bars against people, then we are left with not racism, but just human biases and those apply in all sorts of ways with all sorts of impacts.
But race has effects! Blacks make only 60% of the money that whites do! Here culture comes into play more than race. See the Journal of Epidemiology from July 15,1999 for a study that indicates when you adjust for educational and marital differences as well as for criminal history, there is a 2% bias in income in favor of self identified blacks! This means that the reason for the difference is that the black culture promotes less education, lack of stable families, and more criminal behavior. And these are the primary factors reducing the income statistics. If you decide to get a college degree, get into a stable relationship, and don't knock over gas stations, you will do better than most whites! There are similar studies, by the way, for women. When adjusted for time in work place without interruption, women do better than men. But as we are a free nation, women can choose to stay home and raise families for 5-10 years out of the workforce. Blacks can choose to drop out of school and be "playas". Just don't blame it on race.